Do parents have favourites?

Catching leaves

The Girl is really doing my head in at the moment, and to be honest, I’m kind of relieved.

For the first three years of her life, I cuddled her, carried her everywhere, dressed her, slept in her bed with her if she had nightmares or growing pains or just wanted company in the night, let her off eating the rest of her dinner if she didn’t fancy it. My husband, the Fairy Godmother and I even sing to her in glorious three part harmony if we are all around when she wakes up at night. (As you can imagine, this has done nothing to decrease the frequency of nightwaking.)

In short, I have doted on her. She is simply the cutest, squidgiest, most adorable little person to ever dance around on two legs and then fall flat on her face.

Meanwhile, the Boy was difficult.

When he was two, I had a baby to deal with and I had to push him to be more independent. He got on with it and worked out how to dress and undress, climb into the bath by himself and learned to read himself stories for good measure.

When he was three, he started developing a will of Valyrian steel. It drove me nuts. Mainly, I was just outraged that he would defy me at all. For what seems like ages we locked horns. I would lay down the law – he would pursue his own, clearly superior plan. It took The Husband and I over a year to work out the best ways of challenging his behaviour and leading it down better, more acceptable paths.

It seemed to me, on a daily basis, like my interactions with the Boy were mostly negative and my time with the Girl was full of hugs and delight.

I started to worry that I had let myself develop a knee-jerk, negative response to the Boy.

I started to worry that I had A Favourite.

When I was in my early teens there was a period of a few months when I was convinced, with searing jealousy, that my Mum loved my brother more than me. I would catch her looking at him with an adoring look in her eye that spelled it all out plain as day, to my mind. Meanwhile, I felt I was getting all the jobs, the reprimands, the disapproval.

And you know what – maybe I did, at that time. He was a tween and still had a bit of the cute chubby cheeked look while I had just shot up and sprouted spots everywhere. Not so cute. Also, I was a teenager and did more stuff that deserved reprimanding. Also also, I was older and could handle more jobs.

Perhaps, at 3 and 1, the Girl was my favourite of the two. She said adorably cute things and let me dress her and she (mostly) did as I asked. If she was naughty, it wasn’t deliberate.

Fast forward to present day. The Boy at 5 is a delight. He is actually helpful: he can feed the cats, wash up, set the table, pour milk into the Girl’s cereal and has intelligent comments on multiple choice reading exams. He is fascinated by everything, and you can have amazing conversations with him about science and art and religion and you end up feeling like a genius because you know so much (compared to a 5 year old). His favourite pastimes no longer require my input or much supervision: he will play school by himself, he develops and executes craft projects with minimal help and he builds Lego intended for 7 year olds from the “inconstructions”, as he adorably calls them.

The Girl, on the other hand, clearly thinks Valyrian steel is for wimps and sissies and has developed a will made of diamonds. It sparkles so brightly, endears you with its determination and then BAM: she is on the floor wailing, refusing to move when you are already ten minutes late for school pick up.

When she does not want to do something, she will a) ignore you, then b) go limp on the floor refusing to move and c) start crying like you are taking her to prison. And believe me, there are many, very reasonable things that she does not want to do.

The Husband and I are working on strategies, but it may take a year or more to train this one. This time we are more upbeat though. At the table is a 5 year old building Lego, living proof that the threenager can be defeated.

So: do parents have favourites? Yes, yes we do. But who that favourite is depends entirely on who is the most pleasant to be around at the time – which may be different every day.

IMG_6414 (2)


10 responses

  1. Love this Judith and I feel the same, in that favourites very much change! I sometimes worry like you that LM is my favourite, usually when she is being adorable and Monkey a complete nightmare. Then she throws a big tantrum while Monkey is being an angel and I remember it is not that simple! Great post xx

  2. This is really lovely to read, as my daughter is 2.5 and son is 6 months. Up until now, NG (girl) has been clear favourite as the first few months with the baby were SO. HARD. But now … well, I don’t feel as guilty after reading this post! 🙂 Thanks – really great and thought-provoking. x

    • I think I had that too in the very beginning. My son was def my favourite as I *knew* him. The Girl was still a stranger to me and all she did was cause me pain and keep me awake. But that swapped over and now it is swapping over again! Although ‘favourite’ is really only a very mild preference in the midst of a sea of irrational parental love of course!

  3. I think you’ve hit the nail on he head here Judith. I was always worried that the girls would think I favoured The Boy. The truth is, he’s just easy going and easier to be around than either of them….at the moment! As you rightly point out, they all go through phases and come out the other side. I’m kind of waiting for my boy to ‘turn’, it’s been 11 years!

    • Ooh that’s a very good run of easy going-ness. Does he do his homework? My brother was very easy going but in the teenage years that slipped over the line into apathetic. 🙂 (Sorry brother! You did get out the other side!)

  4. This is exactly right! My eldest thinks I prefer his younger siblings. I don’t, but they are a lot easier than him most of the time! They all have their good days and their bad days and they are constantly changing. They can all be my favourites and sometimes (whisper) I might not actually like them all that much for a few minutes or an hour or two!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s